Supreme Court allows military restrictions on transgender service members

Mike DeNardo
January 22, 2019 - 9:54 am
In this Jan. 7, 2019 photo, the Supreme Court is seen in Washington, D.C.

J. Scott Applewhite/AP Photo


PHILADELPHIA (KYW Newsradio) — The U.S. Supreme Court is allowing the Trump administration's ban on transgender people in the military to go into effect, while challenges continue in lower courts. LGBT activists are continuing to push for the ban to be overturned.

The high court split 5-4 in allowing the plan to take effect, with the court's five conservatives greenlighting it and its four liberal members saying they would not have. The order from the court was brief and procedural, with no elaboration from the justices.

Reinstating the transgender ban will hurt the nation's military readiness, says Jonathan Lovitz, senior vice president of the National LGBT Chamber of Commerce.

"LGBT — particularly trans — service members are willing to fight and even die for their country and are now being told that they are less than any other citizen who'd be willing to do the same," Lovitz said.

Lovitz says if the policy is enforced, it will discourage talented transgender people from ever enlisting in the military.

"It's not only going to hurt those who are currently in the service and are now even more terrified about the prospect of coming out and identifiying themselves as trans, but it's going to block the best and the brightest potential service members from ever enlisting and protecting our country."

Lovitz sauid, "The reinstating of the trans military ban is not just morally and politically wrong. It's economically ruinous for the country." He said the government should realize that allowing transgender people to serve openly in the military and in the workplace makes the eceonomy stronger. 

The Trump administration's policy generally bars transgender people from the armed forces unless they serve "in their biological sex" and do not seek to undergo a gender transition. President Barack Obama's administration had allowed transgender troops to undergo gender transitions while continuing to serve.

The Trump administration had urged the justices to take up cases about the plan directly, but the court declined for now. Those cases will continue to move through lower courts and could eventually reach the Supreme Court again. The fact that five justices were willing to allow the policy to take effect for now, however, makes it more likely the policy will ultimately be upheld.

In a statement released after the court's decision, the Pentagon said that it is critical the department be allowed to "implement personnel policies that it determines are necessary to ensure the most lethal and combat effective fighting force in the world."

Groups that sued over the Trump administration's policy said they ultimately hoped to win their lawsuits against the policy.

"The Trump administration's cruel obsession with ridding our military of dedicated and capable service members because they happen to be transgender defies reason and cannot survive legal review," Jennifer Levi, director of GLAD Transgender Rights, said in a statement.

Until a few years ago, service members could be discharged from the military for being transgender. That changed under the Obama administration. The military announced in 2016 that transgender people already serving in the military would be allowed to serve openly. And the military set July 1, 2017, as the date when transgender individuals would be allowed to enlist.

But after President Donald Trump took office, the administration delayed the enlistment date, saying the issue needed further study. And in late July 2017 the president tweeted that the government would not allow "Transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. Military." He later directed the military to return to its policy before the Obama administration changes.

Groups representing transgender individuals sued, and the Trump administration lost early rounds in those cases, with courts issuing nationwide injunctions barring the administration from altering course. It was those injunctions that the Supreme Court put on hold Tuesday, allowing the Trump administration's policy to take effect.

The Trump administration's revised policy on transgender troops dates to March 2018. The policy generally bars transgender people from serving unless they do so "in their biological sex" and do not seek to undergo a gender transition. But it has an exception for transgender troops who relied on the Obama-era rules to begin the process of changing their gender.

Those individuals, who have been diagnosed with "gender dysphoria," a discomfort with their birth gender, can continue to serve after transitioning. The military has said that over 900 men and women had received that diagnosis. A 2016 survey estimated that about 1 percent of active duty service members, about 9,000 men and women, identify as transgender.


The Associated Press contributed to this report from Washington.